| Name | Years | | Name | Years |
| J.M. Hoffman | 1905 — 1907 | | W. Shank | 1970 — 1971 |
| F. Freeman | 1908 | | John Grassi | 1972 — 1973 |
| F.R. Guerin | 1909 — 1910 | | E. Barnes | 1974 — 1975 |
| C.H. Day | 1911 — 1915 | | C. Watkins | 1976 — 1977 |
| F. Freeman | 1916 — 1918 | | D. Smith | 1978 — 1979 |
| F. Groendyke | 1919 — 1920 | | E. Tully | 1980 — 1981 |
| L. Robinson | 1921 — 1922 | | C.D. Crotsley | 1982 — 1983 |
| F.R. Guerin | 1923 — 1924 | | J. Eible, Sr. | 1984 |
| G. Delp | 1925 — 1926 | | C. Watkins | 1985 |
| C.M. Day | 1927 — 1928 | | E. Finlay | 1986 — 1987 |
| F. Woodruff | 1929 | | T. Berenbak | 1988 — 1989 |
| G.L. Day | 1930 — 1931 | | J. Hoffman | 1990 — 1991 |
| G. Thompson | 1932 — 1933 | | T. Porter | 1992 — 1993 |
| V. Garabrant | 1934 — 1935 | | F. Scharfenberg | 1994 — 1995 |
| W. Rockafeller | 1936 — 1937 | | T. Porter | 1996 |
| J. Sullivan | 1938 — 1939 | | R. Raymond | 1996 — 1997 |
| C. Moeri, Jr. | 1940 — 1941 | | W. R. Menagh | 1998 — 1999 |
| E. Watkins | 1942 — 1943 | | J. L. Smith | 2000 — 2001 |
| C. Guerin | 1944 — 1945 | | J. Eible, Jr. | 2002 — 2003 |
| W. Menagh | 1946 — 1947 | | T. Berenbak | 2004 — 2005 |
| J. Gunther | 1948 — 1949 | | M. Orgera | 2006 — 2007 |
| R.J. Clark | 1950 — 1951 | | E. Tencza | 2008 — 2009 |
| J.T. Lewis | 1952 — 1953 | | M.S. Bruin | 2010 — 2011 |
| H. Dean | 1954 — 1955 | | R.M. DeNicola | 2012 — 2013 |
| P. Parillo | 1956 — 1957 | | C. Nelson | 2014 — 2015 |
| J. Dormer | 1958 — 1959 | | M.S. Bruin | 2016 — 2021 |
| F. Crammer | 1960 — 1961 | | M. Orgera | 2022 — 2023 |
| H. Traudt | 1962 — 1963 | | G. Wiatroski | 2024 — present |
| R. Sanderson | 1964 — 1965 | | | |
| J. O'Keefe | 1966 — 1967 | | | |
| R. Snedaker | 1968 — 1969 | | | |
